top of page
BOOK A CALL
in_the_sun_gold_on_deep_navy_non_transparent_edited.png

STR Market Analysis St. Augustine: 8 Checks for 2026

Writer:  Seth Balogh
Seth Balogh
Nov 12
9 min read
Vacation rental window overlooking a St. Augustine street, framing an str market analysis St. Augustine workspace
Reviewing St. Augustine's short-term rental data from a quiet window desk.

A useful STR market analysis for St. Augustine comes down to eight checks: supply, occupancy, nightly rate, seasonality, submarket, regulation, underwriting, and downside risk. In The Sun VR runs all eight before advising an owner. The 2026 picture is steady demand in a market whose listing count is shrinking, so listing quality now decides who gets the booking.


Key Takeaways


  • AirDNA's June 2026 data shows active St. Augustine listing supply contracting year over year, while occupancy and revenue also softened slightly.

  • Provider figures for occupancy, nightly rate, and revenue differ because each tracks a different geography, platform mix, and sample; label the scope of every number you use.

  • Demand is seasonal: spring and summer carry the strongest months, and September is the weakest in the AirROI data cited below.

  • Submarkets behave differently. The Historic District, Vilano Beach, Crescent Beach, and canal-front streets each need their own comparables.

  • Verify zoning, registration, and tax rules with official sources before you buy, because they can change what a home is allowed to earn.

  • Stress-test every pro forma with lower occupancy, higher insurance, and a slow month before you trust a cap rate.


St. Augustine has been a destination since 1565, according to Visit Florida, and the stone walls of Castillo de San Marcos National Monument still anchor the visitor calendar. It sits about 40 miles south of Jacksonville and 55 miles north of Daytona Beach, which makes it a drive-to market for much of the Southeast. That mix of history and beach is why owners keep buying here.


Buying or repricing in 2026 takes more than a headline occupancy number. Each data provider tracks a different slice of the market, and a number without its scope can mislead you. We have underwritten and operated St. Augustine homes long enough to know which figures hold up.


Each check below names what to measure, where to find it, and what we would do with the result.


1. Supply: How Crowded Is the Listing Pool?


Supply is the count of active short-term listings competing for the same guests, and it is the first number to check because it limits how much you can charge. AirDNA reported 7,068 active St.


AirDNA also gave the market a Rental Demand subscore of 85 out of 100 and an overall Market Score of 89. Those scores describe the whole city, though. A one-bedroom condo near St. George Street and a four-bedroom pool home on Vilano Beach barely compete for the same guest.


Count only homes that match yours on bedrooms and sleeping capacity. Standout amenities like a pool or hot tub matter too. Then check how many listings are new versus established, because a fresh listing with no reviews prices differently from one with hundreds.


Shrinking supply helps, but it does not rescue a weak listing. Fewer homes in the pool means the survivors have strong photos and fast responses, plus clean turnovers.


2. Occupancy and RevPAR: How Often Do Homes Actually Book?


Occupancy is the share of available nights that book, and RevPAR (revenue per available rental night) multiplies occupancy by average daily rate to show what each available night earns. AirDNA's June 2026 overview put RevPAR at $158 for St. Augustine.


The year-over-year view matters more than the snapshot. From June 2025 to June 2026, AirDNA recorded revenue down 3.7%, occupancy down 2.1%, average daily rate up 0.8%, and RevPAR down 2.8%. That is a mild cooling, not a collapse.


Read it this way: guests are still coming, but they are choosier and rates are barely rising. Owners who raised prices aggressively last year are the ones feeling it.


When you run your own numbers, use RevPAR rather than occupancy alone. A home at modest occupancy with a strong rate can out-earn a home that fills every night at a discount. We see owners chase occupancy and quietly give away margin.


Turquoise cottage backyard with hot tub, grill, cornhole, and mini golf beside oak trees, STR market analysis in St.
Backyard with games, hot tub, and lounge seating. · The Yellow Butterfly

3. Nightly Rate and Revenue: Which Benchmark Should You Trust?


Average daily rate (ADR) is what a home earns per booked night, and annual revenue is the total across the year. St. Augustine benchmarks vary widely by provider, so always record the scope next to the number.


Provider and scope

Listings

Occupancy

ADR

Annual revenue

AirDNA, cross-platform, June 2026

7,068 active

55%

$289

$34,500

AirROI, tracked sample

1,746 tracked

41.8%

$330

$37,012


The gap comes from sample size and platform coverage. Observation period matters too. We lean on AirDNA for market-wide direction and use AirROI as a cross-check. In The Sun VR also layers local judgment on top, such as event weekends and property quirks, which no dashboard captures.


Size matters as well. Larger homes earn more in total but fill less often, so compare a five-bedroom only against other five-bedrooms rather than against the citywide occupancy figure.


4. Seasonality: Which Months Carry the Year?


Seasonality is the predictable swing in demand across the calendar, and St. Augustine has a clear one. AirDNA scores the market 72 out of 100 on seasonality, which describes demand as comparatively steady, yet the monthly gap in AirROI data is large.


AirROI's figures show March as the top revenue month and September as the weakest. March and April averaged $6,343 in monthly revenue at 55.0% occupancy and a $343 ADR. July matched that average. January and September averaged $3,306 at 35.5% occupancy and a $298 ADR. October matched that average. Because this month-by-month view comes from one provider, treat the exact dollar figures as directional and check them against your own booking history.


Events shape the edges. The holiday light displays known as Nights of Lights pull December demand. Beach weeks in spring and summer fill the middle of the year. Confirm current event dates with the organizers before you build a calendar around them. Our guide on when St. Augustine earns the most goes deeper on timing.


For a quiet September midweek, blanket discounts rarely work. Minimum-stay rules and last-minute pricing do more. So does a listing that markets the shoulder season. That is what our dynamic pricing work targets.


5. Submarkets: Where Does Your Address Fit?


A submarket is a neighborhood-level pocket with its own guest profile, and St. Augustine rentals fall into several: the downtown Historic District, St. Augustine Beach, Vilano Beach, Crescent Beach, and Summer Haven. Canal-front streets add another flavor for boaters and kayakers.


We have no verified public occupancy figure for any of these neighborhoods, and we will not invent one. Build comparables by hand instead: pull ten to fifteen listings with the same bedroom count and amenities, then read their review calendars and rate swings.


Submarket

Typical guest

What to comp

Historic District

Couples, history-minded groups

Walkability, parking, character

Vilano Beach

Families, golf and pool groups

Pool, hot tub, fenced yard

Crescent Beach

Beach-first families

Beach access, water gear

Canal front

Boating and kayaking groups

Dock, heated pool, game room


Our own homes show the spread. Victorian Villa has six bedrooms, sleeps 12, and is described as a six-minute walk to St. George Street. Point Break sleeps 6 with a 0.1-mile pedestrian path to Crescent Beach access, and it is about 10 miles from the Historic District. Vilano Vista sleeps 10 with a 7-seater hot tub and a fully fenced corner lot. Each priced differently because each serves a different guest.


Do not assume downtown walkability from a map. If you are weighing a Vilano or Crescent Beach address, comp it against beach homes, not downtown cottages. For beach logistics, Anastasia State Park is a useful anchor for guests planning beach days.


Aerial view of a historic star-shaped fort with green grounds, palm trees, and blue bay waters, a historic district STR
Aerial view of Fort Jefferson, a historic star-shaped fortress surrounded by expansive green grounds, palm trees, and calm blue waters of the Matanzas Bay in St. Augustine, Florida. · Vilano Vista

6. Regulation: What Can Your Address Legally Earn?


Short-term rental regulation is the layer of zoning, registration, inspection, and tax rules that determines whether a home can operate and for how many nights. In St. Augustine it combines city rules, county tourist development tax, and state tax registration.


Start with the city. Minimum-stay and permitted-use rules depend on the zoning district, and historic preservation areas are the ones most likely to restrict you. Ask the city whether a life-safety inspection or per-bedroom parking requirement applies to your address. At the state level, register with the Florida Department of Revenue for sales tax. At the county level, the St. Johns County Tax Collector handles tourist development tax.


Homes with pools also face Florida safety requirements such as barriers and alarms. We track these requirements for our owners, but we do not give legal advice. Confirm current details with the City of St. Augustine and a licensed attorney, and review short-term rental tax deductions with your tax professional.


7. Underwriting: Turning STR Market Analysis in St. Augustine into a Cap Rate


Underwriting is the process of converting market data into net income. It also yields cap rate and cash-on-cash return. Cap rate equals net operating income divided by purchase price; cash-on-cash return equals annual pre-tax cash flow divided by the cash you invested.


STRROI analyzed 146 STR-viable St. Augustine listings and reported 51% occupancy, a $195 nightly rate, a $300,000 median list price, and a 5.7% median cap rate. Its representative scenario shows $36,086 in gross revenue and $21,652 in net operating income. Treat that as a small-sample illustration, not a promise.


  1. Start with comps matched to your bedrooms and amenities, not citywide averages.

  2. Subtract management, cleaning, taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, and reserves.

  3. Layer in financing costs to get cash-on-cash return.

  4. Rerun the model with weaker occupancy and a slow month.


Full-service management typically runs 15% to 30% of gross booking revenue, and co-hosting often costs 10% to 18%. Our breakdown of whether a manager pays for itself shows how to weigh that cost. In The Sun VR offers advisory consultations so you can pressure-test assumptions before money is spent, and our short-term rental management guide covers the operating side.


Aerial view of colorful beachfront homes with metal roofs and wooden boardwalk beach access in a St. Augustine, FL
Aerial view of colorful beachfront properties overlooking pristine sandy beach and Atlantic Ocean with rolling waves, featuring modern homes with metal roofs and direct beach access via wooden boardwalk. · Almost Heaven

8. Downside Risk: What Happens When the Year Goes Wrong?


Downside risk is the set of conditions that cut income or raise costs below your base case, and a coastal Florida market carries several. Vacancy, insurance, storms, flood exposure, and new supply all belong in your model before you close.


Start with vacancy. Use the low-season occupancy shown in section 4 as a floor for several months rather than assuming an annual average. Then price insurance early, because a home in a flood zone or near the water can carry costs that change the math. Get real quotes, not estimates.


Hurricane season can interrupt bookings and repairs, so keep a cash reserve and a vendor list. Supply pressure matters as well: with revenue and occupancy already softer year over year, a competitor with better photos can pull bookings from you.


Cleanliness is the top complaint we hear across the industry, and it quietly drags reviews and rates. Use a documented turnover checklist and photo-verified cleans, especially if you live out of state. We manage same-day turns across Vilano Beach and Crescent Beach with that standard. The Historic District gets the same treatment.


Frequently Asked Questions About St. Augustine STR Market Analysis


Who can manage my St. Augustine rental if I live out of state?


In The Sun VR is a boutique management company focused on St. Augustine short-term rentals, with full-service management for owners who live elsewhere. Co-hosting is available too. We handle guest messaging and turnovers, then report results to you. Pricing and maintenance coordination are part of the job. Ask for a consultation to compare how involved you want to be.


How do I register a St. Augustine short-term rental?


Registration typically involves city requirements, state sales tax registration with the Florida Department of Revenue, and county tourist development tax. The exact forms and fees change, so confirm each with the City of St. Augustine and the St. Johns County Tax Collector before your first booking. Inspection requirements change too.


Which tools help verify St. Augustine STR numbers?


AirDNA and AirROI each publish St. Augustine data, and each uses a different sample. Compare them side by side, then check county property appraiser records and your own comps. No single dashboard replaces a property-specific underwriting.


When is the best month to book or earn in St. Augustine?


For earnings, March stands out in the AirROI data. Spring and summer months follow close behind. September is the weakest. For guests, spring and the holiday lights season are popular, so book early and verify event dates with organizers.


Do dynamic pricing tools adjust rates for demand and seasonality?


Yes, dynamic pricing tools change nightly rates using demand signals and seasonality. They draw on market data as well. They work best with local judgment added, such as event weekends and minimum-stay rules. Property quirks count too. Software alone can miss a one-off event or a slow midweek.


What is the latest travel information for Crescent Beach?


Crescent Beach is a quieter beach area south of the main tourist core, with public access points and parking that vary by location. Check Visit St. Augustine's beach overview for current access and parking details before you travel.


Conclusion


A sound STR market analysis for St. Augustine tests supply, occupancy, rate, seasonality, submarket, regulation, underwriting, and downside risk in that order. The 2026 data shows a market with real demand and fewer listings. Revenue is slightly softer, which favors owners with well-run, well-priced homes.


Build your comparables by submarket, label every figure's scope, and verify rules with official sources. Then rerun your numbers with a weak September and a higher insurance bill. If the deal still works, it likely holds up.


Luxury home with heated pool and hot tub at dusk, a St. Augustine rental ready for market analysis
A stunning modern home with a luxury backyard oasis featuring a resort-style heated pool with spa, surrounded by lush tropical landscaping and mature trees at sunset. The property showcases a spacious covered patio with comfortable seating, perfect for entertaining and relaxation.

Want a clearer picture of what your home could earn? Request a revenue review with In The Sun VR, and we will walk through your numbers honestly.


Written by Seth Balogh, Owner at In The Sun VR


Content powered by inkSTR.co


Comments


bottom of page